Mamdani Faces Mounting Criticism From Supporters as Deadly Winter Crisis Exposes Gaps in City’s Homeless Response

Original article here

New York City is confronting a deadly winter crisis, with at least 16 people dying outdoors amid a prolonged stretch of subfreezing temperatures.

City officials are intensifying outreach efforts to protect the homeless, but criticism of Mayor Zohran Mamdani’s policies has grown sharply in recent days.

Thirteen of the fatalities have been linked to hypothermia, while three are suspected drug overdoses. Many of those who died had previously been part of the city’s shelter system, highlighting persistent vulnerabilities among the unhoused population.

“The greatest danger posed by this sustained cold is to vulnerable New Yorkers who remain exposed to the elements,” Mamdani said.

Mamdani’s approach to homelessness has been a key point of contention. Since taking office, he has largely ended the practice of clearing encampments, a policy initiated under former Mayor Eric Adams.

Critics argue that this approach leaves vulnerable individuals exposed during extreme weather events, effectively putting their lives at risk.

Public frustration has been amplified by street conditions during Winter Storm Fern. Residents and local celebrities have criticized uncleared streets, unplowed sidewalks, and accumulated garbage.

Actor Michael Rapaport and actress Debra Messing voiced their disapproval on social media, documenting hazardous conditions and highlighting the contrast with areas near Mamdani’s residence on East 88th Street, which were reportedly cleared promptly.

BizPac Review noted that protesters have gathered outside Gracie Mansion to call for accountability, arguing that city policies have contributed to preventable deaths.

“Clean as a whistle for the mayor,” noted local resident Nick Rivers, highlighting perceived favoritism and uneven enforcement of city services.

The rising death toll underscores the complex challenges city officials face during prolonged cold snaps.

The National Weather Service reports that the current streak of subfreezing temperatures may rank among the longest in city history, comparable to stretches in 1961 and 2018, according to Newsday.

Historically, exposure to extreme cold has claimed dozens of lives in New York annually, with recent years seeing averages higher than previous decades.

Advocates and some city leaders, including Queens Borough President Donovan Richards, have urged more proactive measures to move vulnerable residents indoors.

Nonprofits have distributed blankets branded with the mayor’s name to encourage shelter use, though critics say such efforts are insufficient for those with severe mental illness or substance abuse challenges.

Mamdani has defended his policies, citing a shortage of suitable housing as the root cause of homelessness.

The city has increased staffing, opened additional warming centers, and deployed outreach teams to engage directly with individuals resistant to shelter offers.

Despite these measures, public perception suggests many see the response as inadequate and misaligned with the immediate dangers posed by severe cold, according to the City Journal.

Experts warn that winter fatalities are preventable when local governments act decisively.

In this case, opponents argue that the mayor’s “last resort” approach fails to account for those who cannot make rational decisions about their own safety due to addiction or mental health challenges.

Critics contend that the death toll could have been mitigated with more assertive measures to ensure the vulnerable are not left exposed.

As New Yorkers face continued winter hazards, Mayor Mamdani’s leadership and the city’s infrastructure remain under intense scrutiny.

Officials are balancing limited resources, individual autonomy, and public safety, but the public backlash suggests that many see the city’s efforts as insufficient in the face of preventable fatalities.

The coming weeks will test whether the mayor’s policies can adapt to meet the city’s harsh winter realities or whether criticism will continue to mount.

WATCH: